At the Oregon REALTORS® 2026 Fall Convention, the topic of abuse reporting was discussed at the Principal Broker Forum. Members asked Oregon REALTORS® to provide additional education and resources to help brokers navigate abuse-related situations.
Over the next several weeks, the Tip of the Week will focus on abuse reporting topics. Oregon REALTORS® is also committed to developing a comprehensive abuse-reporting training program for brokers. That training will take time to create, but additional resources are already being developed.
Understanding Capacity Concerns in Real Estate Transactions
By 2050, an estimated 20.8 million people in the United States will be age 85 or older. Research suggests that approximately 35% of individuals in that age group will experience some degree of cognitive impairment or dementia.
This population is expected to control a significant share of personal wealth and maintain one of the country’s highest homeownership rates. As a result, REALTORS® are likely to encounter more transactions involving elderly clients who are downsizing, relocating, or selling long-held family homes.
In some of these transactions, questions may arise regarding a client’s mental capacity.
Many brokers have experienced situations where a family member privately claims that an elderly parent is no longer capable of making informed decisions and asks that all communication be directed through the family instead of the client. Others have encountered clients who appear confused, uncertain about transaction terms, or unable to explain their decisions consistently.
These situations place brokers in a difficult position. Determining legal capacity is not the role of a real estate licensee. However, if circumstances would cause a reasonable person to question a client’s capacity and those concerns are ignored, a broker may face significant scrutiny if the transaction is later challenged.
Several Oregon cases have addressed capacity-related disputes, including Gibson v. Bankofier, Church v. Woods, and White v. McCabe. While each case involved additional legal complexities, they illustrate the risks that can arise when a party’s mental capacity becomes an issue after a transaction.
Oregon’s Presumption of Competence
Oregon law generally begins with the assumption that individuals are competent to enter into contracts unless proven otherwise.
Capacity is also evaluated at the time a specific action is taken. A person may experience periods of confusion or cognitive decline and still possess the legal capacity to complete a particular transaction or make a particular decision.
For that reason, brokers should be cautious about making their own determinations regarding a client’s mental condition.
If a family member tells you that a client lacks capacity, ask whether there has been a medical determination or court ruling addressing the issue. If one exists, request a copy for your records.
Evaluating Potential Capacity Concerns
If no medical or court determination exists, consider involving a disinterested third party in meetings with the client. An independent observer may help confirm or challenge your own observations regarding the client’s understanding of the transaction.
The Oregon State Bar has developed guidance surrounding “contextual capacity.” While it is not a substitute for a medical evaluation, the concepts can be useful when considering whether a client appears to understand the transaction.
Questions to consider include:
- Can the client clearly explain the reasoning behind the decision?
- Has there been noticeable variability in the client’s state of mind, such as mood swings or unexplained behavioral changes?
- Does the client understand the consequences of the decision?
- Does the client understand that a decision to buy or sell real property may be difficult or impossible to reverse?
- Does the client understand whether the transaction is fair, and can the client explain any reasons for proceeding despite potential disadvantages?
- Is the decision generally consistent with the client’s long-term goals, values, and past behavior?
Why This Matters to REALTORS®
Transactions involving elderly clients are becoming increasingly common as the population ages.
At the same time, cognitive impairment and dementia affect a significant percentage of older adults. REALTORS® may be among the first professionals to notice signs that a client is struggling to understand a transaction or make informed decisions.
Because Oregon presumes competence unless evidence to the contrary exists, brokers should not assume incapacity based on age, appearance, or concerns expressed by family members alone.
However, brokers should also avoid dismissing legitimate concerns when a client’s actions, statements, or understanding raise questions about capacity. Careful documentation, consultation with supervising brokers, and involvement of appropriate legal professionals can help protect both the client and the brokerage.
When Additional Assistance May Be Necessary
The contextual-capacity questions are not intended to replace a medical or legal determination.
If both you and an independent third party believe a client may not understand the nature or consequences of the transaction, consult your principal broker or managing principal broker immediately.